Trump asks to dismiss New York charges after Supreme Court immunity ruling
Former President Trump made his formal push to toss his criminal conviction in the wake of the Supreme Court’s presidential immunity decision, contending he’s being treated “unfairly and unlawfully.”
The 52-page brief, made public on Thursday, insists the Manhattan district attorney’s office (DANY) improperly brought in evidence protected by presidential immunity.
Trump’s lawyers are asking New York Judge Juan Merchan, who oversaw the recent trial, to not only throw out the guilty verdict but also dismiss last year’s indictment.
“The record is clear: DANY was wrong, very wrong,” wrote Trump attorneys Todd Blanche and Emil Bove. “Be that as it may, Your Honor now has the authority to address these injustices, and the Court is duty-bound to do so in light of the Supreme Court’s decision.”
In late May, a New York jury convicted Trump on all 34 counts of falsifying business records with an intent to unlawfully influence the 2016 election by disguising reimbursements to his then-fixer, Michael Cohen, as a legal retainer. Just before Trump won the presidency, Cohen had paid $130,000 to porn star Stormy Daniels to stay quiet about an alleged affair with Trump. Trump denies any affair.
The Supreme Court’s decision last week carving out at least presumptive criminal immunity for presidents’ official acts has given Trump a new pathway to attempt to toss his verdict.
Unlike his three other criminal cases, Trump had not argued he was immune from the hush money charges themselves. But the Supreme Court’s ruling blocks prosecutors from bringing in protected acts as evidence, even if the charges concern unofficial conduct.
Trump contends prosecutors improperly cited official acts as evidence at both his blockbuster trial this spring and last year’s grand jury proceedings that led to the first indictment of a former president in U.S. history.
The evidence in question includes one of Trump’s government ethics forms, some of his social media posts issued while in office and testimony from two of his White House aides.
The former president’s lawyers contend much of it implicated “core” executive functions, which the Supreme Court made clear are absolutely protected.
“In order to vindicate the Presidential immunity doctrine, and protect the interests implicated by its underpinnings, the jury’s verdicts must be vacated and the Indictment dismissed,” Trump’s attorneys wrote.
The brief was filed Wednesday and made public Thursday, the same day as Trump’s originally scheduled sentencing. His judge delayed the sentencing until Sept. 18 so he could first weigh the immunity argument.
Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s (D) office, which did not oppose the delay, previously signaled it believes the conviction should stand. They are due to respond in court filings later this month.
Date: | |
Tag: | New York |
-
The Guardian - World
Biden calls for supreme court changes and decries Trump immunity ruling
President calls immunity principle ‘dangerous’ in Austin speech, and proposes code of conduct and term limits. Joe Biden, in a Monday address calling for sweeping reforms of the US supreme court, said the recent decision granting some immunity to ...5 days ago - Joe Biden -
The Guardian - World
Democrats pitch No Kings Act to override supreme court’s Trump immunity ruling
Bill would stipulate that Congress, not the supreme court, has authority to determine to whom federal criminal laws are applied. US politics – live updates Chuck Schumer will introduce a bill in the Senate today to declare explicitly that ...2 days ago - Donald Trump -
ABC News - Top stories
Mark Meadows asks Supreme Court to intervene in Georgia case, citing Trump immunity
Mark Meadows, the one-time chief of staff to former President Trump, is continuing his monthslong effort to move the Fulton County case against him into federal court.5 days ago - Donald Trump -
ABC News - Top stories
Supreme Court returns Trump Jan. 6 immunity judgment to lower court
One month after the Supreme Court's presidential immunity ruling, the judge overseeing former President Trump's Jan. 6 case now has jurisdiction over the case again.10 hr ago - Donald Trump -
CBS News - Top stories
Biden proposes Supreme Court, presidential immunity reform
The White House detailed Monday how President Biden wants to address Supreme Court reform by implementing term limits and an ethics code for the court's justices. Mr. Biden is also proposing changes to limit presidential immunity. CBS News legal ...5 days ago - Joe Biden -
CBS News - Top stories
Trial judge retakes control of Trump 2020 election case after immunity ruling
The Supreme Court ruled that former presidents are immune from federal prosecution for official acts taken while in office.11 hr ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Trump’s Jan. 6 case officially back in Judge Chutkan’s hands after immunity ruling
Former President Trump’s federal election subversion charges officially returned to his trial judge in Washington, D.C., on Friday to determine the case’s future after the Supreme Court last month carved out immunity for former presidents. ...10 hr ago - Donald Trump -
CBS News - Politics
Trial judge retakes control of Trump 2020 election case after immunity ruling
The Supreme Court ruled that former presidents are immune from federal prosecution for official acts taken while in office.11 hr ago - Donald Trump -
The Wall Street Journal - World
Biden Calls for Overturn of Presidential Immunity: 'The Court Made a Ruling for One'
The president also endorsed proposals for a mandatory ethics code and 18-year term limit for justices.5 days ago - Joe Biden -
ABC News - World
Venezuela's Maduro asks top court to audit the presidential election, but observers cry foul
President Nicolás Maduro has asked Venezuela’s high court to conduct an audit of the presidential election after opposition leaders disputed his claim of victory3 days ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Emhoff acknowledges affair in first marriage: 'I took responsibility'
Second gentleman Doug Emhoff on Saturday acknowledged that his first marriage was rocky and admitted to having an extramarital affair. “During my first marriage, Kerstin and I went through some tough times on account of my actions,” Emhoff said, ...2 hr ago -
The Hill - Politics
What's in the cardboard box medalists get at the Paris Olympics?
As athletes receive the medals during the Olympic Games, they also receive a cardboard box. But what's inside it?3 hr ago - Olympics -
The Hill - Politics
Scaramucci: 'Disaster' if Trump doesn't debate Harris
Former White House communications director Anthony Scaramucci signaled Saturday that former President Trump could face “disaster” if he doesn’t debate Vice President Harris ahead of November. Harris, who was officially nominated Friday to lead the ...3 hr ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Don Lemon's case against Elon Musk 'should settle': Attorney
The lawsuit accuses the billionaire of fraud, misappropriation of Lemon's name, negligent misrepresentation and more.4 hr ago - Elon Musk -
The Hill - Politics
Vance continues attack on Harris's background in Atlanta: 'Pretty weird'
Republican vice-presidential nominee Sen. JD Vance (Ohio) leaned into recent attacks by former President Trump on Vice President Harris's background during a rally in Georgia Saturday, while calling her campaign tactics "pretty weird." Using the ...4 hr ago